First, this is a great package, collecting the 6-prog storyline, but more than that, as the GCD explains: "The story has been substantially tinkered with for US publication. British comic size pages have been slightly stretched, or elongated via extra art to more closely resemble a standard US size page. Furthermore, panels have been re-sized or differently placed to ensure the story runs more smoothly in the US format. In the original printing only some splash pages were in color." I wonder if it wasn't cost-effective, though, since Quality/Fleetway usually stuck to straight reprints.
The only thing it misses, I wouldn't read until years later: the lead here, Chopper, appeared in an earlier Judge Dredd story, putting him in the rarefied ranks of recurring perps. At that point, I think there would've been Judge Death, and Chopper, and that was it! (Maybe Mean Machine Angel.) Previously, Chopper had been a young offender, a graffiti artist in an escalating competition to be "King Scrawler." Years later, he had rehabilitated...to some extent. He had taken up power boarding, or sky-surfing; which wasn't illegal except at lower altitudes. Chopper was determined to not let Mega-City One break him down and make him just another nobody, so was set on making his name by winning the illegal cross-city race, Supersurf 7. Dredd questions Chopper about the race, and knows the score immediately, so he has him put under surveillance.
Chopper gets the call with the meet location in code, and quickly realizes he's being tailed by drone cameras. He considers bagging out, to protect the other racers, but can't bring himself to quit, and cuts a dangerous path through the city to ditch the cameras. Then, a scene familiar to kung-fu movies: introducing a bunch of cool badasses ready to compete in the tournament, most if not all of whom would be dead before long. The Supersurf course wasn't exactly the scenic route, but it was supposed to be a challenge, culminating in taking the Manfred Fox tunnel, backwards, against traffic.
There were fatalities before the pack even gets there, but at Mega-City advertising landmark the Okeydokey Man we maybe see why Supersurf and low-altitude boarding was illegal, as a surfer "shooting the O" wipes out, taking a massive truck with him and causing a massive pile-up. Dredd orders the Judges to "shoot to kill," which hopefully was in the name of public safety and not because the surfers were thumbing their collective nose at the Law.
While most of the racers are shot down, wiped-out, or arrested; it comes down to the previous world champion Yakamoto and Chopper: Yakamoto gets clipped by a truck's mirror and goes down, and Chopper goes back to save him, although Yakamoto still dies from his injuries. Dredd himself arrests Chopper, but he knows Mega-City One won't forget his name, and the Law will never break him...
From the looks of it from various posts of yours regarding his many adventures, no, no he wasn't. I get that he was a necessary force of nature doing a thankless job enforcing the law in his particular time & place, but he does come off a true authoritarian with little to no empathy when it comes to others, especially criminals, even sympathetic ones like this Chopper guy.
ReplyDeleteHe truly is an anti-hero in that respect even if he is a cop, which nowadays, in America, really rings true for too many of them.
As for Chopper's next appearance causing Wagner & Grant to split, it can't be that simple can it? Maybe it was the straw that broke the camel's back & not just the singular cause?
Hoo boy, is it ever complicated ...
ReplyDeleteI don't even know where to start. Let's go with the Wagner/Grant split, which wasn't even truly a split since they'd worked on other projects together right up to Alan's death. It was more that they stopped working together all the time and divided up the strips that were still running semi-regularly at the time. The Last American miniseries that they did for Epic is usually what they said was the cause but a big part of it was the next Chopper story. Grant wanted to kill Chopper but Wagner wanted to keep him around (at least a little longer).
The story that was supposed to be the death of Chopper was by Wagner alone. It wasn't explicitly stated that he was dead at the end, but he was bleeding out so it seemed very likely. A couple years later, they started up the Judge Dredd Megazine and needed Dredd-related stories to fill space. Wagner and Grant were advising editors, and one of the pitches that got approved was a Chopper story by Garth Ennis (who also regretted bringing Chopper back later).
Quality/Fleetway did a lot more editing/coloring of the original art than you might think, a lot of it being criticized by fans of the original material.
My thoughts on Chopper and Dredd as hero/antihero/villain protagonist are way too long to put here. Maybe I'll do another post later, when I've collected my thoughts a bit more.
Thanks for filling in the backstory to this.
DeleteYeah! The link I had at the end made it seem like Grant and Wagner disagreed about Dredd shooting Chopper; but I'm not sure about more than that. (I think Dredd only would when legal, not out of malice.)
ReplyDeleteThat was the basic idea- Chopper's evading arrest but not doing anything to stay out of Dredd's line of fire. Grant wanted Dredd to shoot him for that but Wagner wanted him to let him go, as one of those 'worthy foe' things. The compromise ended up being somebody knocked into Dredd, and Chopper got away in the confusion.
ReplyDeleteStill a bit too much going on in my head to talk about how I view Dredd but I can talk about Chopper a bit. I've never really gotten Chopper's appeal. I can guess, but you'd probably have to have been an idiot kid at around the same time as Chopper. A large portion of 2000 AD fans and creatives were around that age and aged up with the comic's target demographic.
Because Chopper really is an idiot. He makes all these deep-sounding statements but he doesn't really change much of anything or help anybody. Most of Chopper's stories (including the one that was supposed to kill him) involve him making choices that he knows will work out poorly for him. Like goo mentioned above, Supersurfs tend to cause damages and fatalities, and the boarders don't really look out for anybody but themselves and maybe their competitors. Even that first image, of the city cheering Chopper's name, confirms that- Mega-City One citizens are overwhelmingly stupid and they're cheering for someone who made life harder for them and may be indirectly responsible for the death of someone they knew or loved.